5. Corporate tax is a progressive tax and is crucial to reducing inequality
Corporate tax helps prevent the undue concentration of wealth and ensures a more equitable distribution of the tax burden among individuals and businesses.
The World Bank has observed that corporate tax acts as an important backstop to personal income tax, given it limits the scope for tax avoidance by individuals who might otherwise have a strong incentive to incorporate so as to escape personal income tax and shelter wealth.
It is also administratively simple to collect and is ‘progressive’ – as richer households will ultimately bear more payments than poorer households.
Who exactly bears the cost of corporate tax is the subject of heated debate. Over-zealous adherents to Laffer Curve theory will claim that customers and employees bear a large part of the cost of corporate income tax, and that cuts will automatically lead to lower prices, higher wages and a substantial boost in investment.
But real-world studies don’t bear this out: in fact, many indicate that substantial investment boosts rarely materialise and that shareholders are largely the beneficiaries (and that these are concentrated in higher personal income groups). Although it is indisputable that very high rates of corporate income tax will have a material impact on investment decision making by business, as we explore in Beware the pseudo-science of low-tax zealots.
Corporate tax acts as a backstop, ensuring that substantial tax is paid by business owners who otherwise might not pay personal income tax. The Wall Street Journal recently reported that corporate income tax was The Tax That Billionaires Actually Pay.
This followed research that found that corporate tax accounted for 46% of the tax paid by the US’s richest 100 individuals. Moreover, after the US cut corporate tax in 2017, there was a substantial widening of the gap between the amount of tax the ultra-wealthy paid in the US and the tax paid by average Americans.
This is important as people are more willing to pay taxes when their tax system is viewed as being generally progressive. Where there is perceived tax inequity, individuals and businesses are less likely to act morally, and more likely to respond to taxation through noncompliance.
This is why the development of a robust and substantial global minimum corporate tax is so important. The steady global decrease in headline corporate tax rates over recent decades, combined with an almost daily reportage of corporate tax scandals, has eroded public trust in the fairness of the tax system in many parts of the world, with significant consequences for morale and compliance.